Stigma, Incommensurability, or Both? Pathology-First, Person-First, and Identity-First Language and the Challenges of Discourse in Divided Autism Communities
This publication is included in the Autistic Autism Scholarship Project. one author of this publication is identified as autistic in the project.
About the autistic author markerDwyer, P. (2022). Stigma, Incommensurability, or Both? Pathology-First, Person-First, and Identity-First Language and the Challenges of Discourse in Divided Autism Communities. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 43(2), 111-113. https://doi.org/10.1097/dbp.0000000000001054
This publication is integrated into AutiHub through:
Authors
Abstract
There is an intense debate in the autism world between supporters of person-first language (PFL: e.g., “person with autism”) and identity-first language (IFL: e.g., “autistic” and “autistic person”). This controversy can engender intense passion and bitter disagreement, reflected in fiery comments on social media.1 Polarization is high: In one study, people on the spectrum were most likely to rate “autistic” the least offensive of various terms, yet “autistic” was also nearly the most likely to be rated most offensive!2 However, PFL and IFL are not the only ways of describing autism. They were preceded by what might be best described as “pathology-first language” (PathFL). In PathFL, disability labels such as “autistic” are, without reflection on the implications of such language use, allowed to define disabled people as afflicted by pathology and as defective. For example, one 1968 study informs us that the “autistic child” has “a severe disorder” (emphasis in original) that, among other features, is characterized by “a lack of sympathy or empathy”; we are also told that such children are usually “mentally subnormal.”3 Unfortunately, although it is hard to find any principled argument supporting PathFL, some autism studies still seem to use PathFL today.4–6 Person-first language emerged in reaction to PathFL. Advocates of PFL argued that disability should not be allowed to define a person in this negative, stigmatizing way: that instead, terms such as “person with autism” should be used to emphasize individuals' personhood and humanity while relegating their disabilities to being merely one of many personal attributes.7,8 However, IFL advocates such as Sinclair9 found PFL unsatisfactory. From the perspective of these advocates, PFL completely dodged the real problem: the stigmatization of disability itself. As these advocates saw it, PFL, by distancing the person from their disability, was accepting that autism and disabilities were inherently negative: that they could not define someone in a positive way or even that they were inconsistent with personhood.9 IFL advocates also emphasize that PFL is seldom used to refer to nonstigmatized groups.9,10 Superficially, an IFL approach uses the same words used by PathFL—e.g., “autistic”—but their underlying meaning and connotation are entirely different. “Autistic” in PathFL describes a negative pathology; PathFL users seem indifferent to the effects of such discourse on identity. By contrast, “autistic” in IFL suggests that autism should be a positive part of someone's identity, coexisting with other identities (e.g., “a Chinese-Canadian autistic woman”). This does not mean that autism has no existence outside the realm of identity,11 merely that in the IFL approach, autistic people are encouraged to accept, be proud of, and identify with their neurodivergence. This is far from the only autism-related term meaning different things to different people. Another example is “disabled.” Arnhart et al.12 suggest that “disabled” should be viewed as a stigmatizing term. This is perhaps because, for many people, the term “disability” refers to what a person cannot do.8,13 However, in the social model of disability, “disability” has little to do with the person: It refers to the barriers and challenges imposed on people by the society's failure to be accessible and inclusive.14 Still other approaches, such as social-relational and social-ecological models, take intermediate positions.15–17 Thus, there are many meanings of “disabled,” and it is far from clear that they are all inherently stigmatizing. These differences of meaning seem to give rise to incommensurability: a lack of a common standard for comparison or measurement. Major approaches to autism, such as neurodiversity approaches and pathology approaches, are often referred to as Kuhnian “paradigms.”18,19 Owing to the greater heterogeneity of approaches to autism and disability compared with the more monolithic Kuhnian scientific paradigms, I prefer to speak of a multiplicity of “approaches,” but I agree these approaches share several crucial features of paradigms: They are used by more or less distinct communities of people, they dictate a “proper” approach that should be taken by their respective adherents, and—crucially for the topic of this commentary—they involve different ways of defining concepts and of viewing the world.20 Owing to this last point, they are to some degree incommensurable: It is often impossible to match a concept in one approach with an exact equivalent in another approach. This incommensurability problem greatly complicates quantitative measurement of stigma in autism terminology. When the same words have multiple meanings and connotations to different communities, how can researchers classify words as inherently stigmatizing or nonstigmatizing or use these classifications to measure stigma in language use? Indeed, there is a danger that classification of words as inherently stigmatizing or nonstigmatizing could lead to circular reasoning. If researchers based such classifications on their own community's approach to language use, they could conclude that other communities following different approaches use terminology in a stigmatizing way simply because people in these communities follow different approaches than the researchers' own. This may be a limitation of the study conducted by Arnhart et al.12 Fortunately, the challenge of incommensurability need not reduce us to relativism. Kuhnian incommensurability has not prevented science from being generally progressive, nor has it prevented historians of science from understanding outdated paradigms.20,21 Greater engagement can help us overcome incommensurability. Through dialogue and collaboration, people following different approaches can come to appreciate and understand the differences in their lexicons and worldviews.
Bibliography cited by this reference
Cited references are imported from external metadata sources when they are available. The list may be partial.
Cited bibliography overview
These indicators describe the bibliography cited by this publication. An author name is counted each time it appears in one cited reference, so the same person can be counted more than once. Names not yet linked to an author already present in AutiHub are treated as unknown, not as non-autistic. Last computed: 17 Nov 2026 01:01.
- With a DOI
- 18
- Without a DOI, from raw bibliography text
- 4
- References with detected author names
- 23 / 23 (100.0%)
- Without detected author names
- 0
- Without a structured title
- 0
- Without a stable identifier
- 3
- References with raw author names still to review
- 0
- References with external metadata lookup issues
- 0
- From DOI or external metadata
- 64
- From validated raw bibliography text
- 0
- Raw names already validated
- 0
- Raw names still to review
- 0
-
Jim Sinclair *Autistic author. Learn more… (2013). Why I dislike “person first” language . Auton Crit J Interdiscip Autism Stud, 1(2), 2.Type: Journal article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W1829568558Crossref OpenAlex
-
Pieta Shakes , Andrew Cashin (2020). An Analysis of Twitter Discourse Regarding Identifying Language for People on the Autism Spectrum . Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 41(3), 221-228. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Christina Nicolaidis , Dora M Raymaker *Autistic author. Learn more… , Steven K. Kapp *Autistic author. Learn more… , Mel Baggs *Autistic author. Learn more… , Elesia Ashkenazy *Autistic author. Learn more… , Katherine E. McDonald et al. (2019). The AASPIRE practice-based guidelines for the inclusion of autistic adults in research as co-researchers and study participants . Autism, 23(8), 2007-2019. SAGE Publications.AutiHub · Autistic Autism Scholarship Project AutiHub · Documentation center Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Michael Rutter (1968). CONCEPTS OF AUTISM: A REVIEW OF RESEARCH* . Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 9(1), 1-25. Wiley.Type: Journal article DOI: 10.1111/j.1469-7610.1968.tb02204.x OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W2012702290Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Bury (2020). ‟It defines who I am” or “it's something I have”: what language do [autistic] Australian adults [on the autism spectrum] prefer? J Autism Dev Disord.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Eilidh Cage , Jessica Di Monaco , Victoria Newell (2018). Experiences of Autism Acceptance and Mental Health in Autistic Adults . Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 48(2), 473-484. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Solveig Magnus Reindal (2008). A social relational model of disability: a theoretical framework for special needs education? European Journal of Special Needs Education, 23(2), 135-146. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Robert Chapman *Autistic author. Learn more… (2021). Neurodiversity and the Social Ecology of Mental Functions . Perspectives on Psychological Science, 16(6), 1360-1372. SAGE Publications.
-
Jan Tøssebro (2004). Introduction to the special issue: Understanding disability . Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research, 6(1), 3-7. Stockholm University Press.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Joel Crucitti , Christian Hyde , Mark A Stokes (2020). Hammering that Nail: Varied Praxis Motor Skills in Younger Autistic Children . Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 50(9), 3253-3262. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Lorcan Kenny , Caroline Hattersley , Bonnie Molins , Carole Buckley , Carol Povey , Elizabeth Pellicano (2016). Which terms should be used to describe autism? Perspectives from the UK autism community . Autism, 20(4), 442-462. SAGE Publications.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Yang Hu , Alessandra M. Pereira , Xiaoxue Gao , Brunno M. Campos , Edmund Derrington , Brice Corgnet et al. (2021). Right Temporoparietal Junction Underlies Avoidance of Moral Transgression in Autism Spectrum Disorder . The Journal of Neuroscience, 41(8), 1699-1715. Society for Neuroscience.Type: Journal article DOI: 10.1523/jneurosci.1237-20.2020 OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W3096046390Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Pia Bradshaw , Claire Pickett , Mieke L van Driel , Katie Brooker , Anna Urbanowicz (2021). ‘Autistic’ or ‘with autism’? Why the way general practitioners view and talk about autism matters . Australian Journal of General Practice, 50(3), 104-108. The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Morton Ann Gernsbacher (2017). Editorial Perspective: The use of person‐first language in scholarly writing may accentuate stigma . Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 58(7), 859-861. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Simon John , Adrian V Jaeggi (2021). Oxytocin levels tend to be lower in autistic children: A meta-analysis of 31 studies . Autism, 25(8), 2152-2161. SAGE Publications.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Kailes (1985). Watch your language, please . J Rehabil, 51, 68.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Emelia Louise Kilby (1982). Watch Your Language, Please . The Physical Educator, 39(4).Type: Journal article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W2946765434OpenAlex
-
Kristen Bottema-Beutel , Steven K. Kapp *Autistic author. Learn more… , Jessica Nina Lester , Noah Sasson , Brittany N. Hand (2021). Avoiding Ableist Language: Suggestions for Autism Researchers . Autism in Adulthood, 3(1), 18-29. SAGE Publications.
-
Robert Chapman *Autistic author. Learn more… (2020). The reality of autism: On the metaphysics of disorder and diversity . Philosophical Psychology, 33(6), 799-819. Informa UK Limited.
-
Arnhart (2021). The use of person-centered language in scientific research articles focusing on autism . J Dev Behav Pediatr.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Giacomo Vivanti (2020). Ask the Editor: What is the Most Appropriate Way to Talk About Individuals with a Diagnosis of Autism? Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 50(2), 691-693. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Simon M. Bury , Rachel Jellett , Jennifer R. Spoor , Darren Hedley (2023). “It Defines Who I Am” or “It’s Something I Have”: What Language Do [Autistic] Australian Adults [on the Autism Spectrum] Prefer? Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 53(2), 677-687. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Monique Botha *Autistic author. Learn more… , Jacqueline Hanlon , Gemma Williams *Autistic author. Learn more… (2023). Does Language Matter? Identity-First Versus Person-First Language Use in Autism Research: A Response to Vivanti . Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 53(2), 870-878. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.