Mapping definitions of co‐production and co‐design in health and social care: A systematic scoping review providing lessons for the future
Masterson, D., Josefsson, K. A., Robert, G., Nylander, E., & Kjellström, S. (2022). Mapping definitions of co‐production and co‐design in health and social care: A systematic scoping review providing lessons for the future. Health Expectations, 25(3), 902-913. https://doi.org/10.1111/hex.13470
This publication is integrated into AutiHub through:
Authors
Abstract
Abstract Objectives This study aimed to explore how the concepts of co‐production and co‐design have been defined and applied in the context of health and social care and to identify the temporal adoption of the terms. Methods A systematic scoping review of CINAHL with Full Text, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, PubMed and Scopus was conducted to identify studies exploring co‐production or co‐design in health and social care. Data regarding date and conceptual definitions were extracted. From the 2933 studies retrieved, 979 articles were included in this review. Results A network map of the sixty most common definitions and—through exploration of citations—eight definition clusters and a visual representation of how they interconnect and have informed each other over time are presented. Additional findings were as follows: (i) an increase in research exploring co‐production and co‐design in health and social care contexts; (ii) an increase in the number of new definitions during the last decade, despite just over a third of included articles providing no definition or explanation for their chosen concept; and (iii) an increase in the number of publications using the terms co‐production or co‐design while not involving citizens/patients/service users. Conclusions Co‐production and co‐design are conceptualized in a wide range of ways. Rather than seeking universal definitions of these terms, future applied research should focus on articulating the underlying principles and values that need to be translated and explored in practice. Patient and Public Contribution The search strategy and pilot results were presented at a workshop in May 2019 with patient and public contributors and researchers. Discussion here informed our next steps. During the analysis phase of the review, informal discussions were held once a month with a patient who has experience in patient and public involvement. As this involvement was conducted towards the end of the review, we agreed together that inclusion as an author would risk being tokenistic. Instead, acknowledgements were preferred. The next phase involves working as equal contributors to explore the values and principles of co‐production reported within the most common definitions.
Bibliography cited by this reference
Cited references are imported from external metadata sources when they are available. The list may be partial.
-
Hilary Boyd , Stephen McKernon , Bernie Mullin , Andrew Old (2012). Improving healthcare through the use of co-design. PubMed, 125(1357), 76-87.Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W196681201Crossref OpenAlex
-
Elke Loeffler (2021). Co-Production of Public Services and Outcomes . Springer International Publishing.Crossref OpenAlex
-
Glenn Robert , Sara Donetto , Oli Williams (2021). Co-designing Healthcare Services with Patients . In The Palgrave Handbook of Co-Production of Public Services and Outcomes (pp. 313-333). Springer International Publishing.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Edgar S. Cahn (2004). No more throw-away people: the co-production imperative .Type: Book OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W602137246OpenAlex
-
Floriana Fusco , Marta Marsilio , Chiara Guglielmetti (2020). Co-production in health policy and management: a comprehensive bibliometric review . BMC Health Services Research, 20(1), 504-504. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Maria J. Grant , Andrew Booth (2009). A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies . Health Information & Libraries Journal, 26(2), 91-108. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Stephen P. Osborne , Kirsty Strokosch (2013). It takes Two to Tango? Understanding the C o‐production of Public Services by Integrating the Services Management and Public Administration Perspectives . British Journal of Management, 24(S1). Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Bram Verschuere , Taco Brandsen , Victor Pestoff (2012). Co-production: The State of the Art in Research and the Future Agenda . Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 23(4), 1083-1101. Cambridge University Press (CUP).Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Oli Williams , Sophie Sarre , Constantina Papoulias , Sarah Knowles , Glenn Robert , Peter Beresford et al. (2020). Lost in the shadows: reflections on the dark side of co-production . Health Research Policy and Systems, 18(1), 43-43. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.
-
Hannah Snyder , Jon Engström (2016). The antecedents, forms and consequences of patient involvement: A narrative review of the literature . International Journal of Nursing Studies, 53, 351-378. Elsevier BV.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Tony Bovaird (2007). Beyond Engagement and Participation: User and Community Coproduction of Public Services . Public Administration Review, 67(5), 846-860. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Stephen P Osborne , Zoe Radnor , Kirsty Strokosch (2016). Co-Production and the Co-Creation of Value in Public Services: A suitable case for treatment? Public Management Review, 18(5), 639-653. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Michael Clark (2015). Co-production in mental health care . Mental Health Review Journal, 20(4), 213-219. Emerald.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
(n.d.). LoefflerE PowerG BovairdT Hine‐HughesF. Co‐production of health and wellbeing in Scotland Governance International. 2013.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Frances Bunn , Claire Goodman , Bridget Russell , Patricia Wilson , Jill Manthorpe , Greta Rait et al. (2018). Supporting shared decision making for older people with multiple health and social care needs: a realist synthesis . BMC Geriatrics, 18(1), 165-165. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Taco Brandsen , Marlies Honingh (2016). Distinguishing Different Types of Coproduction: A Conceptual Analysis Based on the Classical Definitions . Public Administration Review, 76(3), 427-435. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Tina Nabatchi , Alessandro Sancino , Mariafrancesca Sicilia (2017). Varieties of Participation in Public Services: The Who, When, and What of Coproduction . Public Administration Review, 77(5), 766-776. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Anuradha Joshi , Mick Moore (2004). Institutionalised Co-production: Unorthodox Public Service Delivery in Challenging Environments . Journal of Development Studies, 40(4), 31-49. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Elinor Ostrom (1996). Crossing the great divide: Coproduction, synergy, and development . World Development, 24(6), 1073-1087. Elsevier BV.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
(n.d.). SCIE. Coproduction in Social Care: what it is and how to do it. 2015. Accessed November 21 2021.www.scie.org.ukType: OtherCrossref
-
Roger Dunston , Alison Lee , David Boud , Pat Brodie , Mary Chiarella (2009). Co‐Production and Health System Reform – From Re‐Imagining To Re‐Making . Australian Journal of Public Administration, 68(1), 39-52. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Zoe Radnor , Stephen P. Osborne , Tony Kinder , Jean Mutton (2014). Operationalizing Co-Production in Public Services Delivery: The contribution of service blueprinting . Public Management Review, 16(3), 402-423. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Roger B. Parks , Paula C. Baker , Larry Kiser , Ronald Oakerson , Elinor Ostrom , Vincent Ostrom et al. (1981). CONSUMERS AS COPRODUCERS OF PUBLIC SERVICES: SOME ECONOMIC AND INSTITUTIONAL CONSIDERATIONS . Policy Studies Journal, 9(7), 1001-1011. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Andrea Garlatti , Paolo Fedele , Silvia Iacuzzi , Grazia Garlatti Costa (2019). Coproduction and cost efficiency: a structured literature review . Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 32(1), 114-135. Emerald.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Gordon P. Whitaker (1980). Coproduction: Citizen Participation in Service Delivery . Public Administration Review, 40(3), 240. JSTOR.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
W. H. Voorberg , V. J. J. M. Bekkers , L. G. Tummers (2015). A Systematic Review of Co-Creation and Co-Production: Embarking on the social innovation journey . Public Management Review, 17(9), 1333-1357. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Kirsti Malterud , Kari Tove Elvbakken (2020). Patients participating as co-researchers in health research: A systematic review of outcomes and experiences . Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 48(6), 617-628. SAGE Publications.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Sonia Bussu , Maria Tullia Galanti (2018). Facilitating coproduction: the role of leadership in coproduction initiatives in the UK . Policy and Society, 37(3), 347-367. Oxford University Press (OUP).Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Glenn Robert , Jocelyn Cornwell , Louise Locock , Arnie Purushotham , Gordon Sturmey , Melanie Gager (2015). Patients and staff as codesigners of healthcare services . BMJ, 350, g7714. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Elizabeth B.-N. Sanders , Pieter Jan Stappers (2008). Co-creation and the new landscapes of design . CoDesign, 4(1), 5-18. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex
-
Glenn Robert , Oli Williams , Bertil Lindenfalk , Peter Mendel , Lois M. Davis , Susan Turner et al. (2021). Applying Elinor Ostrom’s Design Principles to Guide Co-Design in Health(care) Improvement: A Case Study with Citizens Returning to the Community from Jail in Los Angeles County . International Journal of Integrated Care, 21(1), 7-7. Ubiquity Press, Ltd..Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Ostrom E (1973). Community Organization and the Provision of Police Services . Community Organization and the Provision of Police Services.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Sara Donetto , Paola Pierri , Vicki Tsianakas , Glenn Robert (2015). Experience-based Co-design and Healthcare Improvement: Realizing Participatory Design in the Public Sector . The Design Journal, 18(2), 227-248. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Rocco Palumbo (2016). Contextualizing co-production of health care: a systematic literature review . International Journal of Public Sector Management, 29(1), 72-90. Emerald.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
David Clarke , Fiona Jones , Ruth Harris , Glenn Robert (2017). What outcomes are associated with developing and implementing co-produced interventions in acute healthcare settings? A rapid evidence synthesis . BMJ Open, 7(7), e014650. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Catherine Needham (2008). Realising the Potential of Co-production: Negotiating Improvements in Public Services . Social Policy and Society, 7(2), 221-231. Cambridge University Press (CUP).Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Micah D.J. Peters , Christina M. Godfrey , Hanan Khalil , Patricia McInerney , Deborah Parker , Cassia Baldini Soares (2015). Guidance for conducting systematic scoping reviews . International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare, 13(3), 141-146. Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health).Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Teresa Sofia Amorim Lopes , Helena Alves (2020). Coproduction and cocreation in public care services: a systematic review . International Journal of Public Sector Management, 33(5), 561-578. Emerald.Crossref OpenAlex
-
Anjana E. Sharma , Margae Knox , Victor L. Mleczko , J. Nwando Olayiwola (2017). The impact of patient advisors on healthcare outcomes: a systematic review . BMC Health Services Research, 17(1), 693-693. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Mariafrancesca Sicilia , Alessandro Sancino , Tina Nabatchi , Enrico Guarini (2019). Facilitating co-production in public services: management implications from a systematic literature review . Public Money & Management, 39(4), 233-240. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Qianli Yuan (2019). Co-production of Public Service and Information Technology . Proceedings of the 20th Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research, 123-132. ACM.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Vincent La Placa , Judy Corlyon (2014). Barriers to inclusion and successful engagement of parents in mainstream services: evidence and research . Journal of Children's Services, 9(3), 220-234. Emerald.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Judith Clifton , Daniel Díaz Fuentes , Gonzalo Llamosas García (2020). ICT-enabled co-production of public services: Barriers and enablers. A systematic review . Information Polity, 25(1), 25-48. SAGE Publications.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Suzanne Bench , Erica Eassom , Konstantina Poursanidou (2018). The nature and extent of service user involvement in critical care research and quality improvement: A scoping review of the literature . International Journal of Consumer Studies, 42(2), 217-231. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Stephen L. Vargo , Robert F. Lusch (2008). Service-dominant logic: continuing the evolution . Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36(1), 1-10. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
E. De Weger , N. Van Vooren , K. G. Luijkx , C. A. Baan , H. W. Drewes (2018). Achieving successful community engagement: a rapid realist review . BMC Health Services Research, 18(1), 285-285. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
John Alford (2014). The Multiple Facets of Co-Production: Building on the work of Elinor Ostrom . Public Management Review, 16(3), 299-316. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Huafang Li (2020). Communication for coproduction: a systematic review and research agenda . Journal of Chinese Governance, 5(1), 110-135. Informa UK Limited.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Daniel Masterson , Kristina Areskoug Josefsson , Glenn Robert , Elisabeth Nylander , Sofia Kjellström (2022). Mapping definitions of co‐production and co‐design in health and social care: A systematic scoping review providing lessons for the future . Health Expectations, 25(3), 902-913. Wiley.
-
Stephen L. Vargo , Robert F. Lusch (2004). Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing . Journal of Marketing, 68(1), 1-17. SAGE Publications.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Locock Louise , Boaz Annette (2019). Drawing straight lines along blurred boundaries: qualitative research, patient and public involvement in medical research, co-production and co-design . Evidence & Policy, 15(3), 409-421. Bristol University Press.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Laurel Liang , Albina Cako , Robin Urquhart , Sharon E Straus , Walter P Wodchis , G. Ross Baker et al. (2018). Patient engagement in hospital health service planning and improvement: a scoping review . BMJ Open, 8(1), e018263. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Vicki Tsianakas , Glenn Robert , Jill Maben , Alison Richardson , Catherine Dale , Theresa Wiseman (2012). Implementing patient-centred cancer care: using experience-based co-design to improve patient experience in breast and lung cancer services . Supportive Care in Cancer, 20(11), 2639-2647. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Andrea C. Tricco , Erin Lillie , Wasifa Zarin , Kelly K. O'Brien , Heather Colquhoun , Danielle Levac et al. (2018). PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and Explanation . Annals of Internal Medicine, 169(7), 467-473. American College of Physicians.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
P. Bate , Glenn Robert (2006). Experience-based design: from redesigning the system around the patient to co-designing services with the patient . Quality and Safety in Health Care, 15(5), 307-310. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Sofia Kjellström , Kristina Areskoug Josefsson , Boel Andersson Gäre , Ann-Christine Andersson , Marlene Ockander , Jacob Käll et al. (2019). Exploring, measuring and enhancing the coproduction of health and well-being at the national, regional and local levels through comparative case studies in Sweden and England: the ‘Samskapa’ research programme protocol . BMJ Open, 9(7), e029723. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Michele S. Y. Biddle , Andy Gibson , David Evans (2021). Attitudes and approaches to patient and public involvement across Europe: A systematic review . Health & Social Care in the Community, 29(1), 18-27. Wiley.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Maren Batalden , Paul Batalden , Peter Margolis , Michael Seid , Gail Armstrong , Lisa Opipari-Arrigan et al. (2016). Coproduction of healthcare service . BMJ Quality & Safety, 25(7), 509-517. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Jeffrey L. Brudney , Robert E. England (1983). Toward a Definition of the Coproduction Concept . Public Administration Review, 43(1), 59. JSTOR.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
Sara Donetto , Vicki Tsianakas , Glenn Robert (2014). Using Experience-based Co-design (EBCD) to improve the quality of healthcare: mapping where we are now and establishing future directions . Using Experience‐Based Co‐design (EBCD) to Improve the Quality of Healthcare: Mapping Where We are Now and Establishing Future Directions, 5.Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W2341481909Crossref OpenAlex
-
S Redman , Trisha Greenhalgh , L Adedokun , Sophie Staniszewska , Simon Denegri (2021). Co-production of knowledge: the future . BMJ, 372, n434. BMJ.Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
-
(n.d.). BoyleD HarrisM. The challenge of co‐production. London: New Economics Foundation. 2009. Vol. 56 p. 18.Type: OtherCrossref
-
(n.d.). SlayJ StephensL. Co‐production in mental health: a literature review. London: New Economics Foundation. 2013. p. 4.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Boyle D (2010). Public Services Inside Out. Putting Co‐production into Practice . Public Services Inside Out. Putting Co‐production into Practice.Type: OtherCrossref
-
(n.d.). PerkinsR RepperJ RinaldiM BrownH. Implementing recovery through organisational change: Recovery Colleges Centre for Mental Health. 2012.Type: OtherCrossref
-
(n.d.). DuroseC BeebeejaunY ReesJ RichardsonJ RichardsonL. Connected communities: towards co‐production in research with communities. 2011. Accessed November 21 2021. https://ahrc.ukri.org/documents/project-reports-and-reviews/connected-communities/towards-co-production-in-research-with-communitiesType: OtherCrossref
-
Realpe A (2010). What is Co‐production . What is Co‐production.Type: OtherCrossref
-
Bate P (2008). Bringing User Experience to Healthcare Improvement: the Concepts, Methods and Practices of Experience-based Design . International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance, 21(1). Emerald.Crossref OpenAlex
-
(n.d.). The Point of Care Foundation. EBCD: Experience‐based co‐design toolkit. The Point of Care Foundation. Accessed July 14 2020. https://www.pointofcarefoundation.org.uk/resource/experience-based-co-design-ebcd-toolkitType: OtherCrossref
-
Cahn ES (2000). No More Throw‐Away People: The Co‐production Imperative . No More Throw‐Away People: The Co‐production Imperative.Type: OtherCrossref
-
(n.d.). INVOLVE. Co‐production in Action: Number Two. Southampton: INVOLVE. 2019. Accessed July 14 2021. https://www.invo.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Co-production-in-action-No2.pdfType: OtherCrossref
-
Penny J (2012). People Powered Health Co‐production Catalogue . People Powered Health Co‐production Catalogue.Type: OtherCrossref