Skip to main content
This page is marked noindex, nofollow and nosnippet: search engines are instructed not to index it, follow its links or reuse its content as a search-result excerpt. Citations and proposed references may contain errors or await review; this precaution limits reuse outside their evaluation context.

Citation test result: "Aguirre, 2021, “Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”"

Checked on 15 Nov 2026 16:05 · Calculation version 2026-11-17.10-j20

The bibliographic score measures concordance of the evaluated fields. It is not a probability of certainty or an assessment of the scientific quality of the study.

Scores have been recalculated from the recorded candidate metadata using the current rules, without a new external search.

Share this result

This page is public for sharing but is marked noindex/nosnippet for search engines.

Submitted cited reference

Authors
Aguirre
Year
2021
Title
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Journal
-
DOI
-

Best automated candidate

Title and authors match — metadata incomplete
M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi Google Scholar Exact title, but year differs

M Aguirre. Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre

Cited fields unavailable in candidate metadata: Year.

M2 is retained because its candidate score is higher than M1: 100/100 versus 40/100.

Candidate references (M1 and M2)

These are the candidates from each search channel before final metadata consolidation and validation.

Search channel Jaccard index Source Candidate reference
M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed 20.0% Crossref Sánchez-Santos, Beatriz; Aguirre, Manuel. (2021). The Grammar of a Genre. The Palgrave Handbook of Gothic Origins. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-84562-9_4 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-84562-9_4

Low title correspondence: 20%

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title.

M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi 100.0% Google Scholar M Aguirre. Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre

Title and authors match — metadata incomplete

Cited fields unavailable in candidate metadata: Year.

M2 is retained because its candidate score is higher than M1: 100/100 versus 40/100.

Bibliographic concordance score calculation

The score measures bibliographic concordance; it does not establish that a study exists or that its conclusions are valid.

Bibliographic concordance score : 100/100 · M2 · Title Jaccard : 100 %

M Aguirre. Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre

Title and authors match — metadata incomplete

Cited fields unavailable in candidate metadata: Year.

M2 is retained because its candidate score is higher than M1: 100/100 versus 40/100.

This score (100%) describes the concordance of available metadata for the automated candidate; it is not a validation status.

Evaluated fields: 2 out of 5.

Calculation details
Candidate comparison before metadata consolidation
Search channelCandidate score before consolidationTitle Jaccard
M140/10020.0 %
M2100/100100.0 %
Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
M Aguirre
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant (missing from candidate metadata) — -
Journal
Cited
Not provided
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 100.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.40 (Year missing from candidate metadata: 0.20 removed; Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 100.0

Engine version : 2026-11-17.10-j20

Learn more about the score calculation

Title Jaccard index: 100.0%

Shared significant words / union: 4 / 4.

Shared title tokens: definition; genre; gothic; towards

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

All candidate results

The Grammar of a Genre

Low title correspondence: 20% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 40.0%

Sánchez-Santos, Beatriz; Aguirre, Manuel. (2021). The Grammar of a Genre. The Palgrave Handbook of Gothic Origins. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-84562-9_4

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title.

Authors
Cited
First author : Aguirre
Second author : Not provided
Found
First author : Sánchez-Santos, Beatriz
Second author : Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
The Grammar of a Genre
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 20% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2021
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Not provided
Found
The Palgrave Handbook of Gothic Origins
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.1007/978-3-030-84562-9_4
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 0.0x0.20 + Title 20.0x0.20 + Year 100.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 40.0

Title Jaccard index: 20.0%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 5.

Shared title tokens: genre

Missing title tokens: definition; gothic; towards

Extra title tokens: grammar

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

‘A Dismal Howling’: Formulaic Density and the Gothic Tableau

Low title correspondence: 11.1% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 70.4%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2021). ‘A Dismal Howling’: Formulaic Density and the Gothic Tableau. Studia Anglica Posnaniensia. doi:10.2478/stap-2021-0022

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
‘A Dismal Howling’: Formulaic Density and the Gothic Tableau
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 11.1% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2021
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Not provided
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Studia Anglica Posnaniensia
Volume / issue : 56(1)
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.2478/stap-2021-0022
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 11.1x0.20 + Year 100.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 70.4

Title Jaccard index: 11.1%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 9.

Shared title tokens: gothic

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; towards

Extra title tokens: density; dismal; formulaic; howling; tableau

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Gothic Drift: The Case of ‘Raymond’ and ‘Arthur Kavanagh’

Low title correspondence: 11.1% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 37.0%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2024). Gothic Drift: The Case of ‘Raymond’ and ‘Arthur Kavanagh’. Gothic Studies. doi:10.3366/gothic.2024.0184

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title, Year. Year: 2021 cited; 2024 in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
Gothic Drift: The Case of ‘Raymond’ and ‘Arthur Kavanagh’
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 11.1% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2024
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Not provided
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Gothic Studies
Volume / issue : 26(1)
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3366/gothic.2024.0184
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 11.1x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 37.0

Title Jaccard index: 11.1%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 9.

Shared title tokens: gothic

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; towards

Extra title tokens: arthur; case; drift; kavanagh; raymond

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

‘The Voice of Thunder’: The Formulaic Nature of the Gothic Type-Scene

Low title correspondence: 11.1% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 37.0%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2023). ‘The Voice of Thunder’: The Formulaic Nature of the Gothic Type-Scene. Gothic Studies. doi:10.3366/gothic.2023.0155

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title, Year. Year: 2021 cited; 2023 in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
‘The Voice of Thunder’: The Formulaic Nature of the Gothic Type-Scene
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 11.1% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2023
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Not provided
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Gothic Studies
Volume / issue : 25(1)
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3366/gothic.2023.0155
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 11.1x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 37.0

Title Jaccard index: 11.1%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 9.

Shared title tokens: gothic

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; towards

Extra title tokens: formulaic; nature; thunder; type-scene; voice

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Geometries of Terror: Numinous Spaces in Gothic, Horror and Science Fiction

Low title correspondence: 9.1% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 36.4%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2008). Geometries of Terror: Numinous Spaces in Gothic, Horror and Science Fiction. Gothic Studies. doi:10.7227/gs.10.2.2

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title, Year. Year: 2021 cited; 2008 in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
Geometries of Terror: Numinous Spaces in Gothic, Horror and Science Fiction
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 9.1% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2008
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Not provided
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Gothic Studies
Volume / issue : 10(2)
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.7227/gs.10.2.2
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 9.1x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 36.4

Title Jaccard index: 9.1%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 11.

Shared title tokens: gothic

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; towards

Extra title tokens: fiction; geometries; horror; numinous; science; spaces; terror

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Gothic Fiction and Folk-Narrative Structure: The Case of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

Low title correspondence: 8.3% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 36.1%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2013). Gothic Fiction and Folk-Narrative Structure: The Case of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. Gothic Studies. doi:10.7227/gs.15.2.1

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title, Year. Year: 2021 cited; 2013 in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
Gothic Fiction and Folk-Narrative Structure: The Case of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 8.3% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2013
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Not provided
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Gothic Studies
Volume / issue : 15(2)
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.7227/gs.15.2.1
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 8.3x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 36.1

Title Jaccard index: 8.3%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 12.

Shared title tokens: gothic

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; towards

Extra title tokens: case; fiction; folk-narrative; frankenstein; mary; s; shelley; structure

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

A Gothic-Folktale Interface

Low title correspondence: 16.7% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 38.9%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2019). A Gothic-Folktale Interface. Gothic Studies. doi:10.3366/gothic.2019.0020

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title, Year. Year: 2021 cited; 2019 in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
A Gothic-Folktale Interface
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 16.7% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2019
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Not provided
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Gothic Studies
Volume / issue : 21(2)
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3366/gothic.2019.0020
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 16.7x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 38.9

Title Jaccard index: 16.7%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 6.

Shared title tokens: gothic

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; towards

Extra title tokens: folktale; interface

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Hyphenated words split for this comparison: gothic-folktale → gothic folktale.

Formulaic Language

Low title correspondence: 0% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 66.7%

Aguirre, Manuel. (2021). Formulaic Language. The Palgrave Handbook of Gothic Origins. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-84562-9_5

Divergent or partially matching elements: Title.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
Aguirre, Manuel
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
Formulaic Language
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
2021
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Not provided
Found
The Palgrave Handbook of Gothic Origins
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.1007/978-3-030-84562-9_5
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 0.0x0.20 + Year 100.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 66.7

Title Jaccard index: 0.0%

Shared significant words / union: 0 / 6.

Missing title tokens: definition; genre; gothic; towards

Extra title tokens: formulaic; language

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre

Title and authors match — metadata incomplete M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi Google Scholar SerpApi rank 1 Candidate score before consolidation (M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi) : 100.0%

M Aguirre. Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre

Cited fields unavailable in candidate metadata: Year.

Authors
Cited
Aguirre
Found
M Aguirre
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Title
Cited
“Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre.”
Found
Towards a Definition of the Gothic Genre
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Year
Cited
2021
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant (missing from candidate metadata) — -
Journal
Cited
Not provided
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 100.0x0.20 + Title 100.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.40 (Year missing from candidate metadata: 0.20 removed; Journal absent: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 100.0

Title Jaccard index: 100.0%

Shared significant words / union: 4 / 4.

Shared title tokens: definition; genre; gothic; towards

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.