Skip to main content
This page is marked noindex, nofollow and nosnippet: search engines are instructed not to index it, follow its links or reuse its content as a search-result excerpt. Citations and proposed references may contain errors or await review; this precaution limits reuse outside their evaluation context.

Citation test result: "- Ryfman, P. (2016). Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge. Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd., p. 18-29)…"

Checked on 14 Oct 2026 20:03 · Calculation version 2026-11-17.10-j20

The bibliographic score measures concordance of the evaluated fields. It is not a probability of certainty or an assessment of the scientific quality of the study.

Scores have been recalculated from the recorded candidate metadata using the current rules, without a new external search.

Share this result

This page is public for sharing but is marked noindex/nosnippet for search engines.

Submitted cited reference

Raw citation
- Ryfman, P. (2016). Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge. Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd., p. 18-29). La Découverte.
Authors
Ryfman; P
Year
2016
Title
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Journal
Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
DOI
-
Pages
18-29

Best automated candidate

Low title correspondence: 30%
M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Low title lexical similarity; no validated corresponding reference

Ryfman, Philippe. (2000). L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction. CEMOTI. doi:10.3406/cemot.2000.1515

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2000 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; CEMOTI in the candidate record.

Only M1 has a usable candidate in the recorded search results.

Candidate references (M1 and M2)

These are the candidates from each search channel before final metadata consolidation and validation.

Search channel Jaccard index Source Candidate reference
M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed 30.0% Crossref Ryfman, Philippe. (2000). L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction. CEMOTI. doi:10.3406/cemot.2000.1515 https://doi.org/10.3406/cemot.2000.1515

Low title correspondence: 30%

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2000 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; CEMOTI in the candidate record.

Only M1 has a usable candidate in the recorded search results.

Bibliographic concordance score calculation

The score measures bibliographic concordance; it does not establish that a study exists or that its conclusions are valid.

Bibliographic concordance score : 20/100 · M1 · Title Jaccard : 30 %

Ryfman, Philippe. (2000). L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction. CEMOTI. doi:10.3406/cemot.2000.1515

Low title correspondence: 30%

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2000 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; CEMOTI in the candidate record.

Only M1 has a usable candidate in the recorded search results.

This score (20%) describes the concordance of available metadata for the automated candidate; it is not a validation status.

Evaluated fields: 4 out of 5.

Calculation details
Candidate comparison before metadata consolidation
Search channelCandidate score before consolidationTitle Jaccard
M120/10030.0 %
Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 30% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2000
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : CEMOTI
Volume / issue : 29(1)
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3406/cemot.2000.1515
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 30.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 20.0

Engine version : 2026-11-17.10-j20

Learn more about the score calculation

Title Jaccard index: 30.0%

Shared significant words / union: 3 / 10.

Shared title tokens: humanitaire; l; siecle

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; premier

Extra title tokens: action; cycle; fin; introduction

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

All candidate results

L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction

Low title correspondence: 30% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 20.0%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2000). L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction. CEMOTI. doi:10.3406/cemot.2000.1515

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2000 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; CEMOTI in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
L'action humanitaire. Fin de siècle ou fin de cycle? Introduction
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 30% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2000
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : CEMOTI
Volume / issue : 29(1)
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3406/cemot.2000.1515
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 30.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 20.0

Title Jaccard index: 30.0%

Shared significant words / union: 3 / 10.

Shared title tokens: humanitaire; l; siecle

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; premier

Extra title tokens: action; cycle; fin; introduction

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Une histoire de l’humanitaire

Low title correspondence: 28.6% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 44.6%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2016). Une histoire de l’humanitaire. Repères. doi:10.3917/dec.ryfma.2016.01

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Journal. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; Repères in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
Une histoire de l’humanitaire
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 28.6% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2016
StatusScoreWeight
Concordant 100% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Found
Repères
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3917/dec.ryfma.2016.01
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 28.6x0.20 + Year 100.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 44.6

Title Jaccard index: 28.6%

Shared significant words / union: 2 / 7.

Shared title tokens: humanitaire; l

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; premier; siecle

Extra title tokens: histoire

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Une histoire de l’humanitaire

Low title correspondence: 28.6% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 19.6%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2008). Une histoire de l’humanitaire. Repères. doi:10.3917/dec.ryfma.2008.01

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2008 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; Repères in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
Une histoire de l’humanitaire
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 28.6% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2008
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Found
Repères
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3917/dec.ryfma.2008.01
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 28.6x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 19.6

Title Jaccard index: 28.6%

Shared significant words / union: 2 / 7.

Shared title tokens: humanitaire; l

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; premier; siecle

Extra title tokens: histoire

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

L’héritage des camps de la Retirada au XXI e siècle

Low title correspondence: 18.2% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 34.6%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2015). L’héritage des camps de la Retirada au XXI e siècle. Exils et migrations ibériques aux XX e et XXI e siècles. doi:10.3917/emi.007.0256

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2015 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; Exils et migrations ibériques aux XX e et XXI e siècles in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
L’héritage des camps de la Retirada au XXI e siècle
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 18.2% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2015
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 70% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Exils et migrations ibériques aux XX e et XXI e siècles
Volume / issue : N° 7(1)
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3917/emi.007.0256
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 18.2x0.20 + Year 70.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 34.6

Title Jaccard index: 18.2%

Shared significant words / union: 2 / 11.

Shared title tokens: l; siecle

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; humanitaire; premier

Extra title tokens: camps; e; heritage; retirada; xxi

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

PÉROUSE DE MONTCLOS (Marc-Antoine), L’Aide humanitaire, aide à la guerre? Bruxelles, Complexe, coll. « Enjeux du xxi e siècle », 2001, 208 pages

Low title correspondence: 15% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 16.2%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2002). PÉROUSE DE MONTCLOS (Marc-Antoine), L’Aide humanitaire, aide à la guerre? Bruxelles, Complexe, coll. « Enjeux du xxi e siècle », 2001, 208 pages. Politique africaine. doi:10.3917/polaf.086.0197g

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2002 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; Politique africaine in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
PÉROUSE DE MONTCLOS (Marc-Antoine), L’Aide humanitaire, aide à la guerre? Bruxelles, Complexe, coll. « Enjeux du xxi e siècle », 2001, 208 pages
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 15% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2002
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Politique africaine
Volume / issue : N° 86(2)
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3917/polaf.086.0197g
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 15.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 16.2

Title Jaccard index: 15.0%

Shared significant words / union: 3 / 20.

Shared title tokens: humanitaire; l; siecle

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; premier

Extra title tokens: 2001; 208; aide; bruxelles; coll; complexe; e; enjeux; guerre; marc-antoine; montclos; pages; perouse; xxi

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

ANDRÉANI (Gilles), HASSNER (Pierre) (dir.), Justifier la guerre? De l’humanitaire au contre-terrorisme, Paris, Les Presses de Sciences Po, coll. « Références », 2005, 364 pages

Low title correspondence: 8.7% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 14.7%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2007). ANDRÉANI (Gilles), HASSNER (Pierre) (dir.), Justifier la guerre? De l’humanitaire au contre-terrorisme, Paris, Les Presses de Sciences Po, coll. « Références », 2005, 364 pages. Politique africaine. doi:10.3917/polaf.106.0177a

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2007 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; Politique africaine in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
ANDRÉANI (Gilles), HASSNER (Pierre) (dir.), Justifier la guerre? De l’humanitaire au contre-terrorisme, Paris, Les Presses de Sciences Po, coll. « Références », 2005, 364 pages
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 8.7% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2007
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Politique africaine
Volume / issue : N° 106(2)
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.3917/polaf.106.0177a
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 8.7x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 14.7

Title Jaccard index: 8.7%

Shared significant words / union: 2 / 23.

Shared title tokens: humanitaire; l

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; premier; siecle

Extra title tokens: 2005; 364; andreani; coll; contre-terrorisme; dir; gilles; guerre; hassner; justifier; pages; paris; pierre; po; presses; references; sciences

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Contrer la Contre-révolution anti-associative, un objectif de politique internationale

Low title correspondence: 0% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 40.0%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2017). Contrer la Contre-révolution anti-associative, un objectif de politique internationale. doi:10.64628/aak.gq9srgepx

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year. Year: 2016 cited; 2017 in the candidate record. Cited fields unavailable in candidate metadata: Journal.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
Contrer la Contre-révolution anti-associative, un objectif de politique internationale
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2017
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 70% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Found
Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant (missing from candidate metadata) — -
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.64628/aak.gq9srgepx
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 0.0x0.20 + Year 70.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.60 (Journal missing from candidate metadata: 0.20 removed; DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 40.0

Title Jaccard index: 0.0%

Shared significant words / union: 0 / 12.

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; humanitaire; l; premier; siecle

Extra title tokens: anti-associative; contre-revolution; contrer; internationale; objectif; politique

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

ONG françaises et éducation: marginalisation ou réagencement?

Low title correspondence: 0% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 12.5%

Ryfman, Philippe. (2011). ONG françaises et éducation: marginalisation ou réagencement?. Revue internationale d'éducation de Sèvres. doi:10.4000/ries.2206

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2016 cited; 2011 in the candidate record. Journal: Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd cited; Revue internationale d'éducation de Sèvres in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Ryfman
Second author : P
Found
First author : Ryfman, Philippe
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Le premier siècle de l’humanitaire, ou l’hégémonie de la Croix-Rouge
Found
ONG françaises et éducation: marginalisation ou réagencement?
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Year
Cited
2016
Found
2011
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
Journal or publication source : Une histoire de l’humanitaire (3e éd
Volume / issue : Not provided
Found
Journal or publication source : Revue internationale d'éducation de Sèvres
Volume / issue : 58
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.4000/ries.2206
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 0.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 12.5

Title Jaccard index: 0.0%

Shared significant words / union: 0 / 11.

Missing title tokens: croix-rouge; hegemonie; humanitaire; l; premier; siecle

Extra title tokens: education; francaises; marginalisation; ong; reagencement

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.