Skip to main content
This page is marked noindex, nofollow and nosnippet: search engines are instructed not to index it, follow its links or reuse its content as a search-result excerpt. Citations and proposed references may contain errors or await review; this precaution limits reuse outside their evaluation context.

Citation test result: "Berthoz & Hill, 2005. Moral reasoning and empathy in ASD. J Child Psychol Psychiatry."

Read-only replay of the candidates recorded in the corpus, using the current calculation engine. No external search or new saved test was created.

Checked on · Calculation version 2026-11-17.10-j20

The bibliographic score measures concordance of the evaluated fields. It is not a probability of certainty or an assessment of the scientific quality of the study.

Share this result

This page is public for sharing but is marked noindex/nosnippet for search engines.

Submitted cited reference

Raw citation
Berthoz & Hill, 2005. Moral reasoning and empathy in ASD. J Child Psychol Psychiatry.
Authors
Berthoz; Hill
Year
2005
Title
Moral reasoning and empathy in ASD
Journal
J Child Psychol Psychiatry
DOI
-

Best automated candidate

Low title correspondence: 25%
M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Low title lexical similarity; no validated corresponding reference

Berthoz, Alain. (2012). Gaze and Empathy. Simplexity. doi:10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2005 cited; 2012 in the candidate record. Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry cited; Simplexity in the candidate record.

M1 is retained because its candidate score is higher than M2: 18.8/100 versus 6.2/100.

Candidate references (M1 and M2)

These are the candidates from each search channel before final metadata consolidation and validation.

Search channel Jaccard index Source Candidate reference
M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed 25.0% Crossref Berthoz, Alain. (2012). Gaze and Empathy. Simplexity. doi:10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003 https://doi.org/10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003

Low title correspondence: 25%

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2005 cited; 2012 in the candidate record. Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry cited; Simplexity in the candidate record.

M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi 25.0% Google Scholar UM Schaller; M Biscaldi; T Fangmeier. (2019). Intuitive moral reasoning in high-functioning autism spectrum disorder: a matter of social schemas?. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. doi:10.1007/s10803-018-03869-y https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-018-03869-y

Low title correspondence: 25%

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2005 cited; 2019 in the candidate record. Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry cited; Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders in the candidate record.

M1 is retained because its candidate score is higher than M2: 18.8/100 versus 6.2/100.

Bibliographic concordance score calculation

The score measures bibliographic concordance; it does not establish that a study exists or that its conclusions are valid.

Bibliographic concordance score : 18.8/100 · M1 · Title Jaccard : 25 %

Berthoz, Alain. (2012). Gaze and Empathy. Simplexity. doi:10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003

Low title correspondence: 25%

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2005 cited; 2012 in the candidate record. Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry cited; Simplexity in the candidate record.

M1 is retained because its candidate score is higher than M2: 18.8/100 versus 6.2/100.

This score (18.8%) describes the concordance of available metadata for the automated candidate; it is not a validation status.

Evaluated fields: 4 out of 5.

Calculation details
Candidate comparison before metadata consolidation
Search channelCandidate score before consolidationTitle Jaccard
M118.8/10025.0 %
M26.2/10025.0 %
Authors
Cited
First author : Berthoz
Second author : Hill
Found
First author : Berthoz, Alain
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Moral reasoning and empathy in ASD
Found
Gaze and Empathy
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 25% 0.20
Year
Cited
2005
Found
2012
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
J Child Psychol Psychiatry
Found
Simplexity
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 25.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 18.8

Engine version : 2026-11-17.10-j20

Learn more about the score calculation

Title Jaccard index: 25.0%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 4.

Shared title tokens: empathy

Missing title tokens: moral; reasoning

Extra title tokens: gaze

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

All candidate results

Gaze and Empathy

Selected by automated ranking Low title correspondence: 25% M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed Crossref Candidate score before consolidation (M1: Crossref, OpenAlex and PubMed) : 18.8%

Berthoz, Alain. (2012). Gaze and Empathy. Simplexity. doi:10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2005 cited; 2012 in the candidate record. Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry cited; Simplexity in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Berthoz
Second author : Hill
Found
First author : Berthoz, Alain
Second author : Not provided
StatusScoreWeight
Partial 50% 0.20
Title
Cited
Moral reasoning and empathy in ASD
Found
Gaze and Empathy
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 25% 0.20
Year
Cited
2005
Found
2012
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
J Child Psychol Psychiatry
Found
Simplexity
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.12987/yale/9780300169348.003.0003
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 50.0x0.20 + Title 25.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 18.8

Title Jaccard index: 25.0%

Shared significant words / union: 1 / 4.

Shared title tokens: empathy

Missing title tokens: moral; reasoning

Extra title tokens: gaze

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.

Intuitive moral reasoning in high-functioning autism spectrum disorder: a matter of social schemas?

Low title correspondence: 25% M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi Google Scholar Candidate score before consolidation (M2: Google Scholar via SerpApi) : 6.2%

UM Schaller; M Biscaldi; T Fangmeier. (2019). Intuitive moral reasoning in high-functioning autism spectrum disorder: a matter of social schemas?. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. doi:10.1007/s10803-018-03869-y

Divergent or partially matching elements: Authors, Title, Year, Journal. Year: 2005 cited; 2019 in the candidate record. Journal: J Child Psychol Psychiatry cited; Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders in the candidate record.

Authors
Cited
First author : Berthoz
Second author : Hill
Third author : Not provided
Found
First author : UM Schaller
Second author : M Biscaldi
Third author : T Fangmeier
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Title
Cited
Moral reasoning and empathy in ASD
Found
Intuitive moral reasoning in high-functioning autism spectrum disorder: a matter of social schemas?
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 25% 0.20
Year
Cited
2005
Found
2019
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
Journal
Cited
J Child Psychol Psychiatry
Found
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders
StatusScoreWeight
Non-concordant 0% 0.20
DOI
Cited
Not provided
Found
10.1007/s10803-018-03869-y
StatusScoreWeight
Not present (absent) — -

(Authors 0.0x0.20 + Title 25.0x0.20 + Year 0.0x0.20 + Journal 0.0x0.20) / evaluated weight 0.80 (DOI absent: 0.20 removed) = 6.2

Title Jaccard index: 25.0%

Shared significant words / union: 2 / 8.

Shared title tokens: moral; reasoning

Missing title tokens: empathy

Extra title tokens: high-functioning; intuitive; matter; schemas; social

Common words and autism-related domain terms are excluded. Singular/plural and behavior/behaviour variants are tolerated.