The Participatory Zeitgeist: an explanatory theoretical model of change in an era of coproduction and codesign in healthcare improvement

Palmer, V., Weavell, W., Callander, R., Piper, D., Richard, L., Maher, L., Boyd, H., Herrman, H., Furler, J., Gunn, J., Iedema, R., & Robert, G. (2018). The Participatory Zeitgeist: an explanatory theoretical model of change in an era of coproduction and codesign in healthcare improvement. Medical Humanities, 45(3), 247-257. https://doi.org/10.1136/medhum-2017-011398

Publication date: 28 Jun 2018 Added to AutiHub: 18 Jul 2026 Type: Article Article language: English

This publication is integrated into AutiHub through:

Authors

Publication authors
12
Publication authors identified as autistic
0 / 12 (0.0%)

Abstract

Healthcare systems redesign and service improvement approaches are adopting participatory tools, techniques and mindsets. Participatory methods increasingly used in healthcare improvement coalesce around the concept of coproduction, and related practices of cocreation, codesign and coinnovation. These participatory methods have become the new Zeitgeist—the spirit of our times in quality improvement. The rationale for this new spirit of participation relates to voice and engagement (those with lived experience should be engaged in processes of development, redesign and improvements), empowerment (engagement in codesign and coproduction has positive individual and societal benefits) and advancement (quality of life and other health outcomes and experiences of services for everyone involved should improve as a result). This paper introduces Mental Health Experience Co-design (MH ECO), a peer designed and led adapted form of Experience-based Co-design (EBCD) developed in Australia. MH ECO is said to facilitate empowerment, foster trust, develop autonomy, self-determination and choice for people living with mental illnesses and their carers, including staff at mental health services. Little information exists about the underlying mechanisms of change; the entities, processes and structures that underpin MH ECO and similar EBCD studies. To address this, we identified eight possible mechanisms from an assessment of the activities and outcomes of MH ECO and a review of existing published evaluations. The eight mechanisms, recognition, dialogue, cooperation, accountability, mobilisation, enactment, creativity and attainment, are discussed within an ‘explanatory theoretical model of change’ that details these and ideal relational transitions that might be observed or not with MH ECO or other EBCD studies. We critically appraise the sociocultural and political movement in coproduction and draw on interdisciplinary theories from the humanities—narrative theory, dialogical ethics, cooperative and empowerment theory. The model advances theoretical thinking in coproduction beyond motivations and towards identifying underlying processes and entities that might impact on process and outcome. Trial registration number The Australian and New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry, ACTRN12614000457640 (results).

Bibliography cited by this reference

Cited references are imported from external metadata sources when they are available. The list may be partial.

  1. Robert E Drake , Rob Whitley (2014). Recovery and Severe Mental Illness: Description and Analysis . The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 59(5), 236-242. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  2. John Alford (2014). The Multiple Facets of Co-Production: Building on the work of Elinor Ostrom . Public Management Review, 16(3), 299-316. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  3. Victoria Palmer (2006). Narratives beyond civility: moral protest and cooperation in ethical communities .
    Type: Dissertation OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W47711345
    OpenAlex
  4. John Alford (2009). Engaging Public Sector Clients . Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks. Palgrave Macmillan UK.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  5. Theodore R. Schatzki (2002). The Site of the Social . Penn State University Press eBooks. Penn State University Press.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  6. (2007). Bringing User Experience to Healthcare Improvement: the Concepts, Methods and Practices of Experience-based Design . International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance, 20(5). Emerald.
    OpenAlex
  7. John Alford , Sophie Yates (2016). Co‐Production of Public Services in Australia: The Roles of Government Organisations and Co‐Producers . Australian Journal of Public Administration, 75(2), 159-175. Wiley.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  8. Theodore R. Schatzki , Wolfgang Natter (1996). The Social and Political Body .
    Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W344170003
    OpenAlex
  9. Anna Wiewiora , Robyn Keast , Kerry Brown (2016). Opportunities and Challenges in Engaging Citizens in the Co-Production of Infrastructure-Based Public Services in Australia . Public Management Review, 18(4), 483-507. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  10. Miranda Fricker (2007). Epistemic Injustice . Oxford University PressOxford.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  11. Peter Beresford , Suzy Croft (1993). Citizen Involvement: A Practical Guide for Change .
    Type: Book OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W567941463
    OpenAlex
  12. (n.d.). Barlow R. Engaging patients with digital assistance: engagement, paticipation strategies and tactics reflect mindset shift. Healthcare Purchasing News 2016.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  13. Rick Iedema , Eamon Merrick , Donella Piper , Kate Britton , Jane Gray , Raj Verma et al. (2010). Codesigning as a Discursive Practice in Emergency Health Services: The Architecture of Deliberation . The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 46(1), 73-91. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  14. (n.d.). Centre for Mental Health, Department of Health, Mind, NHS Confederation Mental Health Network, Rethink Mental Illness, Turning Point. No health without mental health: implementation framework. London: Mental Health Strategy Branch, 2012.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  15. Mike Crawford , Deborah Rutter , Catherine Manley , Timothy Weaver , Kamaldeep Bhui , Naomi Fulop et al. (2002). Systematic review of involving patients in the planning and development of health care . BMJ, 325(7375), 1263. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  16. Yiannis Gabriel (2004). The Voice of Experience and the Voice of the Expert ‐ Can they Speak to each Other? In Narrative Research in Health and Illness (pp. 168-186). Wiley.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  17. (n.d.). Department of Health. Liberating the NHS: no decision about me without me. England: Department of Health, 2012.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  18. Neil Springham , Stuart Wraight , Carol Prendergast , Japleen Kaur , Frankie Hughes (2011). ResearchNet: research as recovery . Mental Health and Social Inclusion, 15(1), 34-37. Emerald.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  19. (n.d.). Pūras D. Report of the Special Rapporteur on the right of everyone to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health2017 25/9/2017. https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G17/076/04/PDF/G1707604.pdf?OpenElement .
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  20. Trisha Greenhalgh , CLAIRE JACKSON , SARA SHAW , TINA JANAMIAN (2016). Achieving Research Impact Through Co‐creation in Community‐Based Health Services: Literature Review and Case Study . The Milbank Quarterly, 94(2), 392-429. Wiley.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  21. (2003). The site of the social: a philosophical account of the constitution of social life and change . Choice Reviews Online, 40(07), 40-3946-40-3946. American Library Association.
    OpenAlex
  22. (n.d.). World Health Organization. Mental health action plan 2013-2020. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2013.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  23. Denita Cepiku , Filippo Giordano (2014). Co-Production in Developing Countries: Insights from the community health workers experience . Public Management Review, 16(3), 317-340. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  24. Arthur W. Frank (2004). The Renewal of Generosity . University of Chicago Press.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  25. (2010). Unsimple truths: science, complexity, and policy . Choice Reviews Online, 47(10), 47-5604-47-5604. American Library Association.
    OpenAlex
  26. Peter Beresford , Suzy Croft (1993). Citizen Involvement . Macmillan Education UK.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  27. Taco Brandsen , Marlies Honingh (2016). Distinguishing Different Types of Coproduction: A Conceptual Analysis Based on the Classical Definitions . Public Administration Review, 76(3), 427-435. Wiley.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  28. Mary Madden , Ewen Speed (2017). Beware Zombies and Unicorns: Toward Critical Patient and Public Involvement in Health Research in a Neoliberal Context . Frontiers in Sociology, 2, 7. Frontiers Media SA.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  29. Hanna Grundström , Helena Kilander , Per Wikman , Matts Olovsson (2022). Demographic and clinical characteristics determining patient-centeredness in endometriosis care . Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 307(4), 1047-1055. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.
    OpenCitations
  30. Jerome Billeter (2013). No health without mental health: implementation framework .
    Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W1951685534
    OpenAlex
  31. Patrick W Corrigan , Dale Faber , Fadwa Rashid , Matthew Leary (1999). The construct validity of empowerment among consumers of mental health services . Schizophrenia Research, 38(1), 77-84. Elsevier BV.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  32. Donald M. Berwick (2016). Era 3 for Medicine and Health Care . JAMA, 315(13), 1329. American Medical Association (AMA).
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  33. Marianna Fotaki (2015). Co-Production Under the Financial Crisis and Austerity . Journal of Management Inquiry, 24(4), 433-438. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  34. David Clarke , Fiona Jones , Ruth Harris , Glenn Robert (2017). What outcomes are associated with developing and implementing co-produced interventions in acute healthcare settings? A rapid evidence synthesis . BMJ Open, 7(7), e014650. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  35. Alan Cribb , Sharon Gewirtz (2012). New welfare ethics and the remaking of moral identities in an era of user involvement . Globalisation, Societies and Education, 10(4), 507-517. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  36. Ira J. Cohen , Christopher G. A. Byrant , David Jary (1992). Giddens' Theory of Structuration: A Critical Appreciation. Contemporary Sociology, 21(2), 280. SAGE Publications.
    Type: Article DOI: 10.2307/2075513 OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W1992788035
    OpenAlex
  37. Gradinaru (2012). The Paradox of Participation. The power of dominantion and the power of change . Argum: J Sem Discurs Log Argumen Theor Rhetor, 10, 128.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  38. Sandra D. Mitchell (2009). Unsimple Truths . University of Chicago Press.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  39. Michelle Farr (2013). Citizens and the co-creation of public service innovations . Handbook of Innovation in Public Services, 445-458. Edward Elgar Publishing.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  40. Robert Axelrod , William D. Hamilton (1981). The Evolution of Cooperation . Science, 211(4489), 1390-1396. American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS).
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  41. Richardson, Ruth (2004). Narrative Research in Health and Illness . Wiley.
    OpenAlex
  42. Osborne, Stephen P. 1953- , Brown, Louise (2013). Handbook of Innovation in Public Services . Edward Elgar Publishing.
    OpenAlex
  43. Cathal Doyle , Laura Lennox , Derek Bell (2013). A systematic review of evidence on the links between patient experience and clinical safety and effectiveness . BMJ Open, 3(1), e001570. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  44. Alicia Renedo , Cicely Alice Marston , Dimitrios Spyridonidis , James Barlow (2015). Patient and Public Involvement in Healthcare Quality Improvement: How organizations can help patients and professionals to collaborate . Public Management Review, 17(1), 17-34. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  45. Nancy Tomes (2006). The Patient As A Policy Factor: A Historical Case Study Of The Consumer/Survivor Movement In Mental Health . Health Affairs, 25(3), 720-729. Health Affairs Publishing, LLC.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  46. Brad Astbury , Frans L. Leeuw (2010). Unpacking Black Boxes: Mechanisms and Theory Building in Evaluation . American Journal of Evaluation, 31(3), 363-381. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  47. Vicki Tsianakas , Glenn Robert , Jill Maben , Alison Richardson , Catherine Dale , Theresa Wiseman (2012). Implementing patient-centred cancer care: using experience-based co-design to improve patient experience in breast and lung cancer services . Supportive Care in Cancer, 20(11), 2639-2647. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  48. P. Bate , Glenn Robert (2006). Experience-based design: from redesigning the system around the patient to co-designing services with the patient . Quality and Safety in Health Care, 15(5), 307-310. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  49. (n.d.). Bate P, Robert G. Bringing User Experience to Healthcare Improvement: The Concepts, Methods and Practices of Experience Based Design. London: Radcliffe Publishers, 2007.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  50. Sean Matthews (2001). Change and Theory in Raymond Williams's Structure of Feeling . Pretexts: Literary and Cultural Studies, 10(2), 179-194. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  51. Raymond Williams (2006). 3.2. MARXISM AND LITERATURE . In Literary Theories A Reader and Guide. Edinburgh University Press.
    OpenAlex
  52. Salvador Parrado , Gregg G. Van Ryzin , Tony Bovaird , Elke Löffler (2013). Correlates of Co-production: Evidence From a Five-Nation Survey of Citizens . International Public Management Journal, 16(1), 85-112. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  53. Jijian Voronka (2016). The Politics of ‘people with lived experience’ Experiential Authority and the Risks of Strategic Essentialism . Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology, 23(3-4), 189-201. Project MUSE.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  54. Olga Belova , Ian King , Martyna Sliwa (2008). Introduction: Polyphony and Organization Studies: Mikhail Bakhtin and Beyond . Organization Studies, 29(4), 493-500. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  55. Pia H. Bülow (2004). Sharing Experiences of Contested Illness by Storytelling . Discourse & Society, 15(1), 33-53. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  56. Frances Pheasant-Kelly (2016). Towards a structure of feeling: abjection and allegories of disease in science fiction ‘mutation’ films . Medical Humanities, 42(4), 238-245. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  57. Michael Larkin , Zoë V. R. Boden , Elizabeth Newton (2015). On the Brink of Genuinely Collaborative Care . Qualitative Health Research, 25(11), 1463-1476. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  58. Anthony Giddens (1979). Central Problems in Social Theory . Bloomsbury Publishing Plc.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  59. Elke Loeffler , Tony Bovaird (2016). User and Community Co-Production of Public Services: What Does the Evidence Tell Us? International Journal of Public Administration, 48, 1-14. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex
  60. Raymond Williams (1961). The Long Revolution . Columbia University Press.
    OpenAlex
  61. W. H. Voorberg , V. J. J. M. Bekkers , L. G. Tummers (2015). A Systematic Review of Co-Creation and Co-Production: Embarking on the social innovation journey . Public Management Review, 17(9), 1333-1357. Informa UK Limited.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  62. Howard L. Parsons , Anthony Giddens (1980). Central Problems in Social Theory: Action, Structure and Contradiction in Social Analysis. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 41(1/2), 246. JSTOR.
    Type: Article DOI: 10.2307/2107414 OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W2091915526
    OpenAlex
  63. Victoria Palmer , Patty Chondros , Donella Piper , Rosemary Callander , Wayne Weavell , Kali Godbee et al. (2015). The CORE study protocol: a stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trial to test a co-design technique to optimise psychosocial recovery outcomes for people affected by mental illness in the community mental health setting . BMJ Open, 5(3), e006688. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  64. Louise Locock , Glenn Robert , Annette Boaz , Sonia Vougioukalou , Caroline Shuldham , Jonathan Fielden et al. (2014). Using a national archive of patient experience narratives to promote local patient-centered quality improvement: an ethnographic process evaluation of ‘accelerated’ experience-based co-design . Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 19(4), 200-207. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  65. P. W. Corrigan , M. Salzer , R. O. Ralph , Y. Sangster , L. Keck (2004). Examining the Factor Structure of the Recovery Assessment Scale . Schizophrenia Bulletin, 30(4), 1035-1041. Oxford University Press (OUP).
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  66. (n.d.). Donetto S, Tsianakas V, Robert G. Using Experience-based Co-design (EBCD) to improve the quality of healthcare mapping where we are now and establishing future directions. London: Kings College London, 2014.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  67. Yiannis Gabriel (2004). Narratives, Stories and Texts . In The SAGE Handbook of Organizational Discourse (pp. 61-78). SAGE Publications Ltd.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  68. Rebecca J Wright , Karen Lowton , Glenn Robert , Corita R Grudzen , Patricia Grocott (2018). Emergency department staff priorities for improving palliative care provision for older people: A qualitative study . Palliative Medicine, 32(2), 417-425. SAGE Publications.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  69. Maren Batalden , Paul Batalden , Peter Margolis , Michael Seid , Gail Armstrong , Lisa Opipari-Arrigan et al. (2016). Coproduction of healthcare service . BMJ Quality & Safety, 25(7), 509-517. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  70. A. Coulter , L. Locock , S. Ziebland , J. Calabrese (2014). Collecting data on patient experience is not enough: they must be used to improve care . BMJ, 348(mar26 1), g2225-g2225. BMJ.
    Crossref OpenAlex OpenCitations
  71. (n.d.). Australian Government. National standards for mental health services. Australia: Common Wealth of Australia, 2010.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  72. (n.d.). Fairhurst K, Weavell W. Co-designing mental health services – providers, consumers and carers working together. New Paradigm, 2011; Autumn: 54-58.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  73. (n.d.). Goodrick D, Bhagwandas R. Evaluation of mental health experience co-design (MH ECO). Victoria: Department of Health, 2011.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  74. Sara Donetto , Vicki Tsianakas , Glenn Robert (2014). Using Experience-based Co-design (EBCD) to improve the quality of healthcare: mapping where we are now and establishing future directions . Using Experience‐Based Co‐design (EBCD) to Improve the Quality of Healthcare: Mapping Where We are Now and Establishing Future Directions, 5.
    Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W2341481909
    OpenAlex
  75. (n.d.). Isaacs P, Massey D. Mapping the applied ethics agenda. Third annual meeting of the association for practical and professional ethics. Cleveland, OH, 1994.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  76. (n.d.). Palmer V. Narratives Beyond Civility: the role of moral protest and cooperation in ethical communities. Queensland: Queensland University of Technology, 2006.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  77. (n.d.). Williams R. The long revolution. Cardigan: Parthian Press, 2011.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  78. (n.d.). Williams R. Marxism and literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1977:128–35.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  79. D. Grant , C. Hardy , C. Oswick , L. Putnam (2004). The SAGE Handbook of Organizational Discourse . SAGE Publications Ltd.
    OpenAlex
  80. Dainius Pūras (2018). Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Right of Everyone to the Enjoyment of the Highest Attainable Standard of Physical and Mental Health on his visit to Algeria .
    Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W2944944252
    OpenAlex
  81. (n.d.). Sloterdijk P. The aesthetic imperative: writings on art. Oxford: Polity Press, 2017.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  82. Christopher Peacocke , Thomas Nagel (1988). The View from Nowhere. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 48(4), 772. JSTOR.
    Type: Article DOI: 10.2307/2108026 OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W3159332253
    OpenAlex
  83. (n.d.). Nagel T. The view from nowhere. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 1989.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  84. (n.d.). Bryant C, Jary D. Giddens' theory of structuration: a critical appreciation. London, UK: Routledge, 1991.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  85. (n.d.). Butler J. Performativity’s Social Magic. In: Schatzki T, Natter W, eds. The social and political body. New York: The Guilford Press, 1996.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  86. (n.d.). Wittengenstein L. Philosophical investigations. London: Blackwell Publishers, 1953.
    Type: Other
    Crossref
  87. Bryant, Christopher G. (1991). Giddens' theory of structuration a critical appreciation .
    Type: Article OpenAlex: https://openalex.org/W7066329132
    OpenAlex